Ex parte ROUCHON et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1996-2047                                                        
          Application No. 08/274,141                                                  

          of “destructuring the image of the scene, for a given lapse of              
          time, by making inconsistent changes to the camera settings                 
          including modifying the focus of the camera and modifying a                 
          direction of the camera line of sight.”  Appellants’ claim 8                
          recites the step of destructuring, during a predetermined time              
          period, an image of a scene by defocusing the image and                     
          modifying a direction of the line of sight of the camera.                   
          Appellants’ remaining independent claim, claim 10, recites                  
          means for destructuring, during a predetermined time period,                
          an image of a scene by defocusing the image and modifying a                 
          direction of the line of sight of the camera.  Therefore,                   
          Appellants’ claims require that when the scene image is                     
          destructured, not only is the focus of the camera changed, but              
          the line of sight of the camera is also changed.                            
               Turning to Hanafusa, we find that Hanafusa teaches in the              
          abstract that the scene on the infrared detector element is                 
          defocused or placed out of focus by adjusting the focusing                  
          lens.  In particular, we note in column 3, lines 20 through                 
          25, Hanafusa teaches that in monitoring a distant scene, the                
          focusing lens 5 is adjusted so as to focus a near-most                      
          distance while the camera is looking at a distant scene, or in              

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007