Ex parte SCIALLA et al. - Page 6




                Appeal No. 1996-3847                                                                                Page 6                  
                Application No. 08/162,063                                                                                                  

                581-82, 212 USPQ 323, 326 (CCPA 1981).  Furthermore, "[i]n relying upon the theory of inherency,                            

                the examiner must provide a basis in fact and/or technical reasoning to reasonably support the                              

                determination that the allegedly inherent characteristic necessarily flows from the teachings of the                        

                applied prior art."  Ex parte Levy, 17 USPQ2d 1461, 1464 (Bd. Pat. App. & Int. 1990).  While the                            

                claim does not exclude the presence of other thickeners, it does require the composition based on the                       

                three ingredients be self-thickening.  As it has not been established that the composition suggested by                     

                Smith and Erilli is necessarily self-thickening, we will not sustain this rejection.                                        

                Smith in Combination with Erilli and Gosselink                                                                              

                        Gosselink does not cure the deficiencies of Smith in combination with Erilli as discussed above                     

                and therefore we will not sustain the rejection based on the combination of Smith, Erilli and Gosselink.                    

                Overton in Combination with Chung                                                                                           

                        Turning to the rejection of claims 1-8, 11, and 14-19 as obvious over Overton and Chung, we                         

                note that Overton teaches a self-thickening bleach-containing acidic cleaning composition (col. 1, lines                    

                58-60).  The viscosity range overlaps that claimed.  The composition includes a thickening sulphonic                        

                anionic surfactant (col. 2, lines 7-10) which may be an ammonium salt (col. 3, lines 11-14) in a                            

                concentration of 0.5 to 20 weight percent preferably 1 to 7.5 weight percent (col. 3, lines 28-31).  The                    

                broad range overlaps the claimed range and the preferred range is within the claimed range of 0.1 to 8                      

                weight percent.  The composition optionally includes up to 5 weight percent co-surfactants such as                          

                secondary alcohol ethoxylates within the claimed class (col. 3, lines 41-43) and anionic linear alkyl                       








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007