Ex parte WOLTER-DOLL - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1996-4124                                                        
          Application No. 08/307,088                                                  


          which grinds two adjacent tooth flanks of adjacent teeth of a               
          tooth wheel.                                                                
               Further, claim 28 contains the limitation of                           
          "continuously measuring a grinding force which is applied by                
          the grinding disc."  In determining the scope of this                       
          limitation, we note that the specification does not define                  
          "continuously measuring a grinding force . . . during regular               
          grinding of the tooth wheel."  On page 8 of the specification,              
          Appellant identifies that each sensor monitoring the grinding               
          force has an associated analog to digital (A/D) converter                   
          which provides the sensed value to a CPU.  Thus, the measured               
          data is digital, and thereby is a periodic sampling.  On page               
          3 of the specification, Appellant identifies that the force                 
          value is measured during the course of the machining process.               
          Thus, we find that the scope of the limitation "continuously                
          measuring a grinding force" limitation includes that the                    
          grinding force is continuously sampled through- out the                     
          grinding of the toothed wheel.                                              
               In summary, we find that the scope of independent method               
          claim 28 includes a specific grinding disc which grinds two                 
          adjacent tooth flanks of adjacent teeth of a tooth wheel,                   
                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007