Ex parte SONG et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-0413                                                        
          Application No. 08/231,570                                                  

          the provision of a real image of such size so as to require                 
          magnification in order to be clearly seen by a normal human                 
          eye.  This would appear to have been provided by forming the                
          array of pixels on a single semiconductor chip and we find no               
          contention by the examiner that the skilled artisan would not               
          have been able to have constructed such a device.  We find no               
          problem with enablement of the invention set forth in instant               
          claims 31 and 32.                                                           
               Finally, we turn to the rejections based on prior art.                 
          Since the propriety of all of the rejections depends on                     
          whether it was proper to combine the two primary references to              
          Wells and Lowell, we focus on these references.                             
               Wells clearly is directed to similar subject matter as                 
          the instant claimed invention in the disclosure, within a                   
          portable communication receiver, of a miniature virtual image               
          display [see Figure 4 of Wells] having a viewing aperture,                  
          being operably attached to the receiver and including image                 
          generating apparatus [real image of LED display 46 is provided              
          and lenses 54 and 56, along with housing 52, provide a virtual              
          image] for providing a real image and a fixed optical system                



                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007