Ex parte VALYI - Page 3




             Appeal No. 1997-0731                                                                                 
             Application 08/362,151                                                                               


             adherence between the blank and injected plastic and enhances                                        
             bonding of the blank to the injected plastic.                                                        



                                               THE REFERENCES                                                     
             Valyi                              3,939,239        Feb. 17,                                         
             1976                                                                                                 
             Hanamoto et al. (Hanamoto)         4,639,341        Jan. 27,                                         
             1987                                                                                                 
             Yabe et al. (Yabe)                 4,898,706        Feb.  6,                                         
             1990                                                                                                 
                                                THE REJECTION                                                     
                    Claims 1-3, 5 and 7-11 stand rejected under Hanamoto in                                       
             view of Valyi and Yabe.                                                                              
                                                    OPINION                                                       
                    We have carefully considered all of the arguments                                             
             advanced by appellant and the examiner and agree with                                                
             appellant that the aforementioned rejection is not well                                              
             founded.  Accordingly, we reverse this rejection.                                                    
                    Appellant's claims 1, which is the sole independent                                           
             claim, requires that the color coated blank has a roughened                                          
             surface which promotes greater adherence between the blank and                                       
             injected plastic and enhances bonding of the blank to the                                            
             injected plastic.  Appellant argues that the applied                                                 

                                                      -3-3                                                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007