Ex parte SINIAKEVITH - Page 5




             Appeal No. 1997-0793                                                                                 
             Application 08/107,633                                                                               


             gas stream (12) that includes hydrocarbon gases and tar fumes                                        
             (col. 2, lines 1-6 and 23-32).                                                                       
                    Step b: The carbonaceous material from the semi-coking                                        
             reactor is gasified in a combustion chamber (9) to which air                                         
             is added and a gas generator (18) to which steam is added                                            
             (col. 2, lines 6-11 and 33-55).  There is no disclosure that                                         
             air must be excluded from the gas generator.  Consequently,                                          
             the reference indicates that the method is open to the                                               
             presence of air which, as indicated by Reh (col. 1, lines 22-                                        
             24), was a known gasifying                                                                           




             agent for solid fuels.  Reh teaches that use of oxygen from                                          
             air in the gasification of solid fuels has the benefit of                                            
             providing control of the gasification temperature and product                                        
             composition (col. 3, lines 7-14; col. 4, lines 22-23).  Thus,                                        
             one of ordinary skill in the art would have been led by the                                          
             applied prior art to allow some air to be present to avoid the                                       
             expense of sealing the system against air, and further would                                         
             have been led to use air, if desired, to obtain the benefit                                          
             disclosed by Reh of the oxygen in the air.  Both the                                                 
                                                      -5-5                                                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007