Ex parte GUPTA - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-0846                                                        
          Application No. 08/474,950                                                  


          Admitted Prior Art.  Essentially, for the reasons set forth in              
          appellant's brief, we do not find the stated rejection to be                
          well taken.  As emphasized by appellant, the appealed claims                
          are directed to a removable, non-brittle, water soluble                     
          thermoplastic spacer for use to space an electrical component               
          from a printed circuit wiring board to which the electrical                 
          component will be attached.  Baechtold does not relate to the               
          technology of concern to appellant.  What Baechtold's                       
          described invention relates to is a water-soluble, heat-                    
          sealable film material suitable for use                                     
          1) as a water soluble wrap or 2) for fabrication into water-                
          soluble envelopes.  Baechtold's film material and water                     
          soluble wrap is used for the packaging of household materials               
          intended to be dissolved or dispersed in water, for example,                
          soap powder or detergent powder.  That appellant acknowledges               
          (specification page 2) that wash away lactose spacers have                  
          been used to space an electrical component from a printed                   
          wiring board in the prior art does not aid the examiner's                   
          rejection, since there is no indication in Baechtold that the               
          prior art water-soluble film and wrap material would overcome               
          the problems relating to the use of the prior art lactose                   
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007