Ex parte LEWIS et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1997-1014                                                        
          Application 07/991,013                                                      


          indication, to us, that there is an electrical connection                   
          between the module and the main body.                                       
               However, even though Takagi may show an electrical                     
          connection between the main body and the module, the instant                
          claims still require that the electrical circuit of the module              
          execute communication programs and applications in cooperation              
          with the electrical circuits of the apparatus.  The examiner’s              
          rejection provides no showing of this limitation in any of the              
          applied references nor does the examiner come to grips with                 
          the question as to why it would have been obvious to modify                 
          the applied references.                                                     
               Since the module must be capable of executing                          
          communication programs and applications, the module must have               
          a processor.  There is no indication that the telephone                     
          memorandum module of Takagi has such a processor nor is it                  
          seen that such a memorandum module for merely passing data                  
          would require such a processor.  It is likely that the                      
          calculator module of Takagi has its own processor but this                  
          module is not disclosed as being, in any way, electrically                  
          connected to the apparatus.  But even if the module of Takagi               


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007