Ex parte PARKS et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1997-2072                                                        
          Application No. 08/261,544                                                  

          Both Rains and Nodelman, therefore, do not employ diethyl                   
          toluene diamine or other co-chain extenders, including                      
          hindered amines, in their novel reaction mixtures.  See both                
          Rains and Nodelman in their entirety.  Rather, they employ an               
          organic polyisocyanate (inclusive of the claimed                            
          polyisocyanate) or the claimed polyisocyanate, together with                
          the claimed polyether polyol, hydroxyl functional organic                   
          material and active hydrogen containing compound.  See Rains,               
          column 2, lines 43-65 and Nodelman, column 2, lines 5-24 and                
          40-68.  These specific reaction mixtures produce molded                     
          articles having a flexural modulus of at least 750,000 psi and              
          600,000 psi, respectively.  See Rains, column 1, lines 38-48                
          and Nodelman, column 2, lines 32-36 and columns 9 and 10,                   
          Table III.  The molded articles can                                         
          also “withstand heat over a broad range of temperatures up to               
          100 C” and have “a Class A surface.”  See, e.g., Rains, columno                                                                        
          3, lines 2-6.                                                               
               Given the fact that both Rains and Nodelman teach away                 
          from using diethyl toluene diamine and other conventional co-               
          chain extenders, such as hindered amines, we agree with                     
          appellants that the applied prior art references as a whole                 

                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007