Ex parte KOSKINEN et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-2931                                                        
          Application 08/237,034                                                      


               providing independent drive motors for the rolls                       
               used in supporting a web in each treatment station,                    
               e.g., coating and drying including the backing roll                    
               as shown in Fig. 1, in order to control and achieve                    
               proper web tension.  Thus in view of Kuhnel, it                        
               would have been obvious to provide the backing rolls                   
               in Sieberth et al or Murray with independent drive                     
               means in order to achieve proper web tension.                          
               [Answer, page 4.]                                                      
               Hence, it is the examiner’s position that Kuhnel would                 
          have suggested to one of ordinary skill in the art providing                
          the devices of the primary references with drive means for                  
          controlling the speed of the backing roller of one of the                   
          coating applicator and doctor units relative to the other in                
          order to control tensile stress of the web between said units.              
          We do not agree.                                                            
               An objective of Kuhnel is to insure that the web is held               
          taut between the spaced pressure lines resulting from the                   
          applicator nip 17 and the edge of the doctor blade 30 (column               
          5, lines 52-57; column 5, line 71 through column 6, line 1).                
          Kuhnel accomplishes this by controlling a number of operating               
          parameters of the apparatus.  Upstream of the application nip               
          17, the web is subjected to a predetermined amount of inherent              
          tension by an adjustable tension device 26 of the supply roll               
          24 and by snubbing the web around a lead roll 28 before                     
                                         -5-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007