Ex parte NILSEN - Page 12




          Appeal No. 1997-3240                                                        
          Application 08/176,940                                                      

          simultaneous storing of code words for different encoding                   
          levels.  McEntee, in col. 4, lines 13 through 27 and claim 1,               
          teaches a method and an apparatus for cell by cell copying of               
          the active memory objects into a new memory area and updating               
          the pointers to that object.  However, we fail to find any                  
          teachings in McEntee that shows or leads us to Appellant’s                  
          claimed means and method for storing the code words for a                   
          plurality of encoding levels or their equivalent.                           
          Additionally, McEntee merely transfers the objects by exact                 
          copying of each cell but is completely silent with regard to                
          the means and the method for simultaneous storing of a                      
          specified code word through a range of registers at a                       
          plurality of addresses for different encoding levels.                       
          Therefore, the limitation of “means for entering                            
          simultaneously into the code memory at a plurality of                       
          addresses a code word for each of a plurality of encoding                   
          levels,” as recited in Appellant’s claim 1, is absent in                    
          McEntee’s disclosure.  We note that the other independent                   
          claim 8 recites a process for simultaneous entering of code                 
          words similar to claim 1.  Accordingly, we reverse the                      



                                         12                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007