Ex Parte PRINSSEN - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1997-3267                                                        
          Application 08/324,386                                                      



          in a closed space under a positive pressure with respect to the             
          open air” (translation, page 5) and “feeding of the filter in the           
          arrangement . . . can be done . . . [with] the aid of pumps . . .           
          such that the positive pressure in the positive pressure chamber            
          is taken into account” (translation, page 7).  Stahl further                
          shows, in Figure 2, an embodiment having a “product space [that]            
          is kept higher than atmospheric pressure” and where it is                   
          “preferable to use an arrangement which is distinguished by the             
          fact that the pressure difference between the space kept under              
          positive pressure and the product space in a subterranean tunnel            
          can be adjusted up to a maximum value which can be selected                 
          exclusively according to the requirements of the filtration                 
          problem” (translation, page 7).  The appellant argues that there            
          is no teaching or suggestion within Stahl for supplying the                 
          feedstock (25) to the enclosed pressure space at a pressure                 
          greater than atmospheric and that it is clear that the material             
          to be separated is only subjected to the positive pressure when             
          in the positive pressure chamber and not in the prior supply                
          portions, hence the need for the supply pumps to take the                   














Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007