Ex parte MALTBY et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-3433                                                        
          Application 08/395,548                                                      

          Large OBject or "BLOB" where "BLOB's [sic] typically comprise               
          items such as very large graphic data, OLE annotations or                   
          files to be transferred" (col. 13, lines 63-65).                            
               Thessin discloses transferring OLE annotations, but,                   
          aside from the agent structure in figure 2, does not disclose               
          the mechanism for transferring an OLE annotation from a first               
          computer to a second computer.  Nevertheless, the Examiner                  
          finds (FR4-5):                                                              
               Thessin et al. explicitly teach the well-known OLE                     
               protocol [col. 8, lines 35[-]47, col. 9, lines 13 - 23],               
               hence, Thessin et al. inherently teach the following                   
               steps of:                                                              
                    ! receiving notification that the first application               
               has submitted material to the clipboard on the first                   
               computer and obtaining a list of available formats for                 
               said submitted material [col. 8, lines 35[-]47, col. 9,                
               lines 13 - 23];                                                        
                    ! transmitting the format(s) corresponding to Object              
               Embedding to the second computer [col. 8, lines 35[-]47,               
               col. 9, lines 13 - 23];                                                
                    ! submitting the format(s) corresponding to Object                
               Embedding to the clipboard at the second computer for                  
               selection by the second application [col. 8, lines 35[-                
               ]47, col. 9, lines 13 - 23].                                           
               However, Thessin et al. do not explicitly disclose using               
               the clipboard to transmit and submit the format(s)                     
               corresponding to Object Embedding for selection by an                  
               application.                                                           


                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007