Ex parte GILPATRICK - Page 4




               Appeal No. 1997-4392                                                                                                    
               Application No. 08/639,515                                                                                              


               stitches” that bridge the thread 16.                                                                                    



                       Eschenbach discloses a method of forming twisted slub yarn comprising a core yarn 10 and an                     

               effect yarn 12.  To accomplish this, the path of the effect yarn 12 being fed into an air jet 14 is                     

               lengthened by a path deviator assembly 50, thereby reducing the linear velocity of the feed of the effect               

               yarn into the air jet 14. When a solenoid valve 74 is intermittently deactivated, the effect yarn is                    

               released from the expanded position and the excess yarn is sucked into the air jet 14,  wherein the                     

               filaments of the effect yarn 12 are allowed to curl into loopy yarn and intermingle with the filaments of               

               the core yarn 10.                                                                                                       


                       It is the examiner’s position that Altman discloses securing loopy yarn to a sheet to form a                    

               female connector member, but that Altman does not disclose adhesively securing the loopy yarn onto                      

               the sheet.  It is also the examiner’s position (answer, pg. 5) that it would have been obvious to use                   

               adhesive to secure the loopy yarn 16 of Altman onto the sheet 11 since,  a) Altman discloses (col. 2,                   

               lines 11-12) that the loopy yarn may be “secured to material 11 in any suitable manner,” b) securing                    

               loopy material to a sheet is “old” in the art, and c) adhesive securing is simpler and more effective than              

               stitching.  The examiner further  explains (answer, pg. 5) that since there is suggestion in Altman to                  

               provide more than one loopy yarn on the sheet:                                                                          

                                                                                                                                      

                                                                  4                                                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007