Appeal No. 1997-4395 Application No. 08/351,044 32. In an automatic phonograph having a compact disc player adapted to read from a compact disc encoded information as to the starting time, ending time, and reported elapsed playing time of each selection on the disc, apparatus comprising: means responsive to starting a selection for generating a measured elapsed time signal synchronized with a reported elapsed time signal read from the disc; means for comparing said measured elapsed time signal with said reported elapsed time signal; means responsive to said comparing means for recording a skip when the difference between said measured elapsed time signal and said reported elapsed time signal is greater than a predetermined amount; and means for resynchronizing said measured elapsed time signal to correspond with said reported elapsed time signal upon the occurrence of said skip so that subsequent skips can be detected and recorded. There are no references relied on by the examiner. The parent application was the subject of Appeal 1994- 0365 decided January 31, 1994, in which a panel of this Board in-part affirmed the rejection of claims 3 through 9 under the enablement portion of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. § 112, while reversing the rejection of the examiner as to claims 1 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007