Ex parte HAWKES - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1997-4463                                                        
          Application 07/988,712                                                      

               Bullock does not disclose "means responsive to the                     
          operation of the input device for one of said sites for                     
          initiating the reading out of a message to be provided at the               
          site from the means for addressably storing [at the common                  
          source]" (emphasis added).  The Examiner states that Bullock                
          stores the message at the common site 16 and at each remote                 
          site 18 (SEA4).  However, this does not address the claim                   
          limitation which requires the message to be read out from the               
          common source, not just stored at the common source.  It is                 
          clear that Bullock reads out the message from the local memory              
          at the user unit, not from a common source at computer 16.                  
               Bullock further does not disclose "the reading out of a                
          message for each site  . . . proceeding concurrently for all                
          sites at a rate for each site which depends on an information               
          utilization rate for the site."                                             
               The Examiner realizes that outputting the messages from                
          the central processor at a rate that corresponds to the                     
          utilization rate is not performed because the site-specific                 
          messages are stored at the site (EA10).  The Examiner states                
          (EA10-11):                                                                  
               However, if the related product information were                       
               extensive (audio data can often require excessive                      
                                       - 11 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007