Ex parte KOPISH - Page 15




          Appeal No. 1998-0236                                                        
          Application No. 08/472,536                                                  

          In any case, there is no teaching in this reference that the                
          joint between the hinged table top panels 39 overlies the                   
          cross piece 28 of the table’s frame.  Tasaka, on the other                  
          hand, does disclose a bed construction, but there is no                     
          teaching in this reference of any stringers or cross members                
          underlying the bottom wall panels 11.                                       
               For the foregoing reasons, we cannot sustain the two                   
          rejections of claim 17.  For the same reasons we cannot                     
          sustain the rejections of claims 18 through 23 which depend                 
          directly or indirectly from claim 17.  As noted supra with                  
          regard to the rejection of claim 1, Nelson does not rectify                 
          the foregoing shortcomings of Hannum and Tasaka.                            
               With regard to claim 30, Bianco discloses an upper bed                 
          section and a lower furniture section having furniture                      
          components such as storage drawers 26 and dresser 28.                       
          However, Bianco concededly lacks a teaching of providing                    
          separable post assemblies for removably mounting the upper bed              
          section 20 on the lower furniture section.                                  
               Perkins, however, teaches a modular furniture system                   
          having upper and lower furniture sections 12 and 14 supported               
          on corner post assemblies.  Each of the post assemblies                     

                                          15                                          





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007