Appeal No. 1998-0558 Application No. 08/564,942 invention as an improvement over the C alkyl aromatic 8 hydrocarbon isomerization disclosed by Riehm (page 3 of specification, lines 19-24) "by limiting the temperature of the reduction step in the activation of the catalyst to no more than 340 degrees celsius" to attain reduced xylene ring loss during the process (page 3 of the specification, lines 13-15). Accordingly, appellant does not dispute the examiner's factual determination that Riehm, Berger and the admitted prior art teach a process for isomerizing C alkyl- 8 aromatic hydrocarbons by contact with a hydrogenation- dehydrogenation catalyst comprising a Group VIII metal such as palladium or platinum in the presence of hydrogen, as well as separating the effluent from the reactor to hydrogen-rich and hydrocarbon-rich fractions and recycling an aromatic-rich fraction back to the isomerization zone. While the examiner recognizes that Riehm, Berger and the admitted prior art do not disclose appellant's activation of the catalyst 7Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007