Ex parte CAMPO et al. - Page 9


          Appeal  No. 98-0588                                                          
          Application 08/501,293                                                       

          the selected host computer.  (Paper No. 22 at 3).                            
               We will first address appellants’ second argument and                   
          then address appellants’ first and third arguments together.                 
          While we agree with appellants that Reddersen does not teach a               
          scanner having a transmitter, or a host computer having a                    
          receiver, we disagree with appellants that Tymes fails to                    
          teach these features.  Tymes generally teaches a data                        
          transmission system for linking a plurality of bar code                      
          readers with a host computer through intermediate computers,                 
          or intermediate base stations.  The bar code readers                         
          communicate with the intermediate computers over an RF link.                 
          (Tymes at abstract).  The bar code readers have a radio                      
          transceiver 44 which, depending on a switch setting, functions               
          as both a radio receiver and radio transmitter, for receiving                
          information from the intermediate computers and for                          
          transmitting information to the intermediate computers.                      
          (Tymes, Fig. 4, column 8, lines 41-45, Fig. 9, column 15,                    
          lines 58-60).  Tymes further describes that the radio                        
          transceiver 44 and the antenna 45 are contained within the                   
          scanner housing shown in Fig. 5.  (Tymes, Fig. 5, column 10,                 
          lines 45-50).                                                                
               Tymes further teaches that associated with each                         
          intermediate computer is a radio transceiver 34 connected to                 

                                           9                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007