Ex parte LEE - Page 3




         Appeal No. 1998-1811                                                      
         Application No. 08/395,193                                                

              selecting a program to be edited, using time information             
         of said video and audio signals, said time information being              
         recorded together with said video and audio signals in a                  
         recording mode;                                                           
              retrieving a program with time information of the program            
         selected at the program selecting step from the programs                  
         recorded on the recording medium of said playback mechanism;              
         and                                                                       
              copying the program retrieved at the retrieving step on              
         the recording medium of said recording mechanism;                         
              wherein the program selecting step includes:                         
              a single program selecting step of selecting a plurality             
         of programs of a single periodic time slot using said time                
         information; and                                                          
              a plural program selecting step of selecting a successive            
         series of programs of different time slots using said time                
         information.                                                              
              The Examiner relies on the following prior art:                      
         Beaulier                      4,568,981               Feb. 04,            
         1986                                                                      
         Chippendale                   4,858,033               Aug. 15,            
         1989                                                                      
         Lee                           5,291,301               Mar. 01,            
         1994                                                                      
                                                (filed Jul. 08, 1992)              
         Matsumi et al. (Matsumi)          5,479,299                Dec.           
         26, 1995                                                                  
                                                (filed Feb. 06, 1992)              
              Claims 2-4, 6, and 10-13 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C.              
         § 103.  As evidence of obviousness, the Examiner offers                   
         Chippendale in view of Lee with respect to claims 2-4, adding             


                                        3                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007