Ex parte RICHARDS - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1998-1981                                                        
          Application No. 08/695,899                                                  


          able to avoid high electric field strengths in the semi-                    
          conducting glaze on said portion of said insulator.                         
               Appellant's claim 9 further recites "[a] surface current               
          conduction and strength means . . . for providing mechanical                
          strength for support of said volume current conveyance means."              
          In the Examiner's Answer, the Examiner states that Tsuzuki                  
          teaches a surface current conduction and strength means as                  
          shown as Element 9 in the Tsuzuki Figure.                                   
               Turning to Tsuzuki, we note that in column 3, lines 8                  
          through 11, Tsuzuki teaches that the thickness of the alloy                 
          portion 9 is shown on an enlarged scale in the Figure.                      
          Furthermore, Tsuzuki teaches in column 3, lines 12 through 16               
          that the low melting point alloy portion 9 may be formed by                 
          melt- spray or metallized on the semi-conducting glaze 4.                   
          Thus, Tsuzuki teaches that Element 9 is a very thin foil                    
          applied over the semi-conducting glaze 4.  Therefore, we fail               
          to find that the Element 9 provides any mechanical strength                 
          for support of the volume current conveyance means.                         
               Therefore, we fail to find that Tsuzuki teaches all of                 
          the elements as recited in Appellant's claim 9.  Therefore, we              

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007