Ex parte DE BYKHOVETZ et al. - Page 2




           Appeal No. 1998-2057                                                  Page 2              
           Application 08/331,541                                                                    


                 We AFFIRM-IN-PART and REMAND.                                                       
                 The subject matter on appeal relates to a golf club                                 
           belonging to the category of irons and to a set of iron golf                              
           clubs.  According to the specification, the purpose of the                                
           invention is to offer golfers the opportunity to clear                                    
           relatively high and distant obstacles with precision (page 3).                            
                 A copy of the appealed claims appears in an appendix to                             
           the brief.                                                                                
                 The prior art references of record relied upon by the                               
           examiner in rejecting the appealed claims are:                                            
           Pfau                                3,416,797                           Dec.              
                                                                 17, 1968                            
           Carl Paul, Golf Clubmaking and Repair, Paul Associates,                                   
           Austin, Texas, 1984, pages 193, 194, 291, 299, 344, 346-348,                              
           363, 364, 396, 456, 457, 468 and 469 (hereinafter referred to                             
           as “Paul”).                                                                               
                 An additional reference relied upon by this panel of the                            
           Board in a remand to the examiner is:2                                                    
           Divnick                       5,133,553                           Jul. 28,                
           1992                                                                                      
           (filed Feb. 14,                                                                           
           1991)                                                                                     

                 Claims 18 through 35 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. §                               

                 2A copy of the reference is enclosed with this decision.                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007