Ex parte GASKILL - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1998-2693                                       Page 6           
          Application No. 08/569,976                                                  


               The examiner alleges, "switch 44 in Berry et al. is                    
          manually operable to provide full control of the receiver; one              
          skilled in the art would have recognized full control to                    
          include 'enabling and disabling the receiver's stored                       
          addresses.'"  (Examiner's Answer at 7.)  The appellant argues               
          that in Berry "there is no command to change the address to                 
          which the receiver responds."  (Appeal Br. at 4.)                           


               Claims 1 and 15 specify in pertinent part the following                
          limitations: "multiple storage locations containing stored                  
          Selectable receiver addresses; a manually operable selection                
          means located on said receiver for enabling and disabling                   
          stored receiver addresses ...."  Similarly, claims 16 and 17                
          specify in pertinent part the following limitations: "storing               
          multiple receiver addresses in each one of the receivers, each              
          stored receiver address associated with a different receiver                
          user;                                                                       
          receiving the signals with the RF receivers; ... and manually               
          selectively enabling and disabling at said receiver the stored              
          receiver addresses thereby selectively changing the data                    
          supplied to the receivers for each user."  Accordingly, claims              







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007