Ex parte PEDRAJA et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1998-2708                                                        
          Application No. 08/459,361                                                  

               Appellants further argue that neither Gillig nor Morais                
          teaches or suggests wireless terminal stations (WTS) which are              
          inhibited or enabled by a control means (EDC) depending on                  
          whether or not a cordless telephone (WT) is being used (brief-              
          pages 13 and 14), regarding claim 1.  The Examiner responds                 
          that Gillig “discloses an ‘audio switch [which] selects                     
          between audio signals of audio circuitry in the cordless                    
          transceiver and audio circuitry in the cellular transceiver                 
          under control of select signals.’ (reference characters                     
          omitted).”  (Answer-page 4.)                                                
               We agree with Appellants.  Gillig’s audio switch                       
          selection is unrelated to inhibiting or enabling a wireless                 
          terminal station (WTS).  In a broad sense, Gillig’s switch                  
          could be considered to be the control means (EDC).                          
          Additionally, when the audio circuitry is disconnected from                 
          the cordless transceiver it would inhibit the cordless                      
          transceiver.  Concurrently, when the audio circuitry is                     
          connected to the cellular transceiver, it would enable the                  
          cellular transceiver.  However, element 10 of Gillig is not a               
          wireless terminal station (WTS) as claimed since it is not                  
          connected to subscriber lines (LS) as claimed.                              

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007