Ex parte FELMUS et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-3359                                                        
          Application 08/572,347                                                      


          teach the discrete time periods established for the execution               
          of motor control functions, but argue that DiGiulio does not                
          allow sufficient time to allow completion of the machine                    
          control algorithms,but instead uses an elaborate priority                   
          system to reallocate time from lower priority functions to                  
          higher priority functions in the event that a higher priority               
          function requires additional processing time to execute to                  
          completion.                                                                 


               On page 6 of the answer, the Examiner argues that                      
          DiGiulio does teach completion of the control algorithms.  The              
          Examiner points us to column 6, line 60, to column 7, line 68.              


               Upon our careful review of DiGiulio, we find that                      
          DiGiulio teaches in column 6, lines 60-63, that the motor                   
          controller 50 performs a control cycle every 1 millisecond as               
          shown in figure 5.  In column 6, lines 65-67, DiGiulio teaches              
          each control cycle is divided into discrete time periods T                  
          during which control functions are performed as noted in table              
          1 illustrated in figure 5.  In column 7, lines 45-46, DiGiulio              


                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007