Ex Parte GOULDSON - Page 6


            Appeal No. 1998-3421                                                    
            Application No. 08/646,995                                              

            issued to Donald F. Morgan on September 24, 1996 (based on              
            an application filed June 7, 1995)3 alone or in combination             
            with the WMRR publication.  The Morgan patent discloses a               
            method of reusing and recycling plastic garment hangers                 
            similar the method disclosed in the WMRR publication.                   
            Morgan, however, is more pertinent than the WMRR                        
            publication in that it expressly teaches the step of                    
            removing size indicating parts from the returned hangers at             
            a reuse collection center 18 (see column 5, lines 56-60).               
            As such, the Morgan patent appears to supply the                        
            deficiencies of the WMRR publication, so that the only                  
            difference between Morgan and the subject matter of claim 1             












                                                                                   
            3 This patent was cited by appellant in a supplemental information      
            disclosure statement (Paper No. 16).                                    
                                         6                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007