Ex parte SCHULZ - Page 4




          Thomas in view of Schulz `983 and Grupe.                                    


               Attention is directed to the appellant's main and reply                
             briefs (Paper Nos. 13 and 15) and to the examiner's answer               
                                       (Paper                                         
                                          3                                           


          Appeal No. 1999-1375                                                        
          Application 08/619,806                                                      

          No. 14) for the respective positions of the appellant and the               
          examiner with regard to the merits of this rejection.                       


                                     DISCUSSION                                       


          Schulz `671 and Thomas, the examiner's alternative                          
          primary references, both disclose a method of producing a                   
          multi-ply paper web.                                                        
          In the context of the terminology employed in                               
          representative claim 1, the Schulz `671 method comprises the                
          steps of embossing a first ply (web 21) between a first pair                
          of rolls including an embossing roll (rigid steel embossing                 
          roll 11) having protuberances (13) formed in a substantially                
          rigid outer surface and a second roll (resilient rubber backup              
          roll 17) having an outer surface formed of a resilient                      






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007