Ex parte GILLESPIE - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1999-1506                                                        
          Application 08/815,151                                                      


          of Crockett's disclosure of bolts 24, 26.                                   
               We will not sustain this rejection.  Crockett does not                 
          dislcose using bolts 24, 26 to lock the ends 20, 22 of members              
          14, 16 into the ladder rung, but rather bolts 24, 26 are                    
          described as "stop bolts," such that (col. 4, lines 34 to 40):              
               When the insertable ends 20 and 22 are inserted into                   
               opposite ends of a ladder rung and the ladder                          
               support 10 is properly installed to the ladder into                    
               which the insertable ends 20 and 22 are inserted,                      
               stop bolt 24 prevents movement of the ladder support                   
               in the direction of stop bolt 26 and stop bolt 26                      
               prevents movement of the ladder support in the                         
               direction of stop bolt 24.                                             
               We do not read this language as suggesting that bolts 24,              
          26 perform any locking functions, but rather that they act as               
          stops to prevent ends 20, 22 from being inserted too far into               
          the rung.  Thus, since there is no teaching or suggestion in                
          Crockett for the use of bolts as a means for locking a member               
          into a ladder                                                               





          rung, there is no basis for combining the references as the                 



                                         -7-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007