Ex parte BACULY - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1999-1758                                                       
          Application No. 08/787,971                                                 


          (36) to adjust the securing force of the clips (24, 77) to the             
          vertical flange portion (30) of jaws (14, 16).  As is apparent             
          from Figures 1,                                                            
          4-7 and 12 of the application drawings, in order to be able to             
          adjust the securing force of the clips (24, 77), the angled                
          face of the clips (24, 77) are in contact with the rear                    
          vertical edge of the jaws (14, 16).  Thus, we agree with the               
          examiner that the clips (24, 77) contact a rear vertical edge              
          of the flange portion (30) and do not contact a surface of the             
          jaws (14, 16).  Accordingly, the adaptor (22) only contacts a              
          single surface of the vertical flange portion (30) of the jaw              
          and therefore we conclude that an adaptor configured to                    
          releasably engage and grip "at least two adjacent or two                   
          opposing surfaces of a jaw of a beam clamp" is not disclosed               
          in the instant application.                                                


               With respect to appellant’s arguments on page 5 of the                
          Brief, that the above rejection under section 112, first                   
          paragraph, is both procedurally and substantively improper,                
          appellant argues that upon informing the examiner in Paper                 
          No.7 of the location for support of the matter added to claim              
                                         8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007