ESSERMAN et al. V. GAMMIE - Page 2




          Interference No. 104,001                                                    


                           JUDGMENT UNDER 37 CFR 1.662(c)                             
                                    _____________                                     

          METZ, PATE, and MARTIN, Administrative Patent Judges.                       
          MARTIN, Administrative Patent Judge.                                        
                    As a result of the Adminstrative Patent Judge's                   
          decision (Paper No. 81) granting Esserman et al.'s Motion II                
          and order (Paper No. 82) redeclaring the interference, the                  
          only claims of the Esserman et al. patent that remain                       
          designated as corresponding to the count are claims 60 and 68.              
          Esserman et al.'s Motion X, which was contingent on the                     
          granting of their Motion II, requests entry of the                          
          accompanying statutory disclaimer of these claims under 37 CFR              
          § 1.321(a) claims.  This request is being treated as a request              
          for entry of adverse judgment against these claims in                       
          accordance with the last sentence of § 1.662(c), which reads,               
          "A statutory disclaimer will not be treated as a request for                
          entry of an adverse judgment against the patentee unless it                 
          results in the deletion of all patent claims corresponding to               
          a count."   Accordingly, judgment is hereby entered against3                                                                  


            The validity of this provision was upheld in Guinn v.3                                                                      
          Kopf, 96 F.3d 1419, 1422, 40 USPQ2d 1157, 1160 (Fed. Cir. 1996).            
                                          - 2 -                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007