Ex parte DOUCET - Page 14




          Appeal No. 2000-0581                                                        
          Application No. 08/429,155                                                  


          includes the tips and claim 28, in reciting an attaching                    
          device and aligning means, implicitly includes the blade or                 
          (2) an aperture, receptacle, recess, clip, screw or cam                     
          disposed on either the blade or tip constitutes an "attachment              
          means" itself, and an aligning pin, a recess or an abutting                 
          surface disposed on either of the blade or tip constitutes an               
          "aligning means" itself, without the cooperating structure on               
          the other of the tip or blade.                                              
               Additionally, we note that claim 28 recites an "attaching              
          device" and a "fastening means" as separate elements.  This is              
          in contrast to, for example, claim 5, which recites the                     
          attaching devices as further including a fastening means.  In               
          this regard, this recitation in claim 28 also appears to be at              
          odds with page 6 of the specification, which seems to imply                 
          that the fastening means and the threaded receptacle make up                
          the attaching device (the alternative to the snap-on                        
          arrangement of the first embodiment).                                       
               Moreover, the screw 28 or the like, the only "fastening                
          means" disclosed in the specification, does not appear to be                
          part of the blade tip as disclosed.  Rather, the screw or the               
          like fastening means appears to be a separate element which                 
                                         14                                           





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007