Ex parte BALL - Page 3




              Appeal No. 2000-1465                                                               Page 3                
              Application No. 09/037,485                                                                               


                     The appellant’s invention is directed to improvements in strainer assemblies in                   
              which the flange assembly that extends around the opening in the basin can be replaced                   
              when it becomes damaged or discolored without replacing the entire strainer  assembly.                   
              Claim 5 reads as follows:                                                                                
              5.     A strainer assembly for bathtub drains and the like, comprising,                                  
                     a strainer assembly having a circular horizontal flange with a center opening                     
              adapted to fit over and around a vertically disposed drain port in the bottom of a fluid                 
              receptacle,                                                                                              
                     a hollow bushing extension extending downwardly from said center opening and                      
              terminating in an open lower portion with external threads,                                              
                     a hollow attachment bushing having a center opening threadably secured around                     
              said lower portion of said bushing extension and extending downwardly therefrom, said                    
              attachment bushing having a lower open end with at least one crossbar extending                          
              thereacross,                                                                                             
                     a bearing hub formed in the center of said crossbar on the center axis of said                    
              center openings, and                                                                                     
                     a vertically disposed threaded aperture in said hub to threadably receive a                       
              threaded connecting stud from a closure valve,                                                           
                     the attachment bushing having both internal and external threads positioned directly              
              opposite each other on inner and outer internal and external surfaces thereof with the                   
              internal threads threadably receiving the external threads on the open lower portion of the              
              bushing extension.                                                                                       
                    It is the examiner’s view that all of the subject matter rejected in this claim is                
              disclosed in Bergin, except for the separate bushing extension.  However, the examiner is                
              of the opinion that it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to modify the         








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007