Ex parte BENNER - Page 6




            Appeal No. 2000-1856                                                  Page 6              
            Application No. 08/527,671                                                                


            guide rail adapted to substantially mate with said insert and                             
            urge said insert into said pocket” as required in claim 38.                               
            In particular, as explained on page 12 of appellant’s                                     
            specification,                                                                            
                  the guide means 78 includes an elongated, generally                                 
                  semi-circular rail 78a which, as shown in Figure 2,                                 
                  projects downwardly into and substantially mates                                    
                  with the space in the insert superstructure defined                                 
                  between the first web 28, the second web 32 and the                                 
                  upper surface of the platform 24.  Rail 78a                                         
                  functions to positively urge the insert into seated                                 
                  and stable contact with its associated wheel pocket                                 
                  84 as the wheel travels from the first to the third                                 
                  assembly stations described below.  More                                            
                  particularly, the guide rail 78a is adapted to                                      
                  lightly contact the superstructure of insert 14 as                                  
                  the insert traverses the guide means 78 such that                                   
                  the undersurface of the platform remains in abutting                                
                  relation with the ledge 88 while the first insert                                   
                  web 28 and first insert flange 26 maintain abutment                                 
                  with the abutment surface 92 and support surface 94,                                
                  respectively, of the wheel backing plate 90.  The                                   
                  stability thus afforded by the guide means 78                                       
                  assures that the insert is processed and inspected                                  
                  with a high degree of precision as it progresses                                    
                  through the assembly stations of apparatus 10.  Such                                
                  precision, in turn, translates into fewer                                           
                  misassembled cutter bar/insert subassemblies,                                       
                  thereby further enhancing the efficiency of the                                     
                  assembly apparatus.                                                                 

            Neither Acton nor Reid contains any teaching of a guide rail                              
            which mates, in the sense of fitting together, with either of                             
            the parts to be assembled.  There is no indication in either                              
            of these references that the guide rail (ring guide 60 of                                 





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007