Ex parte NOVAK et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-2014                                                        
          Application No. 08/713,672                                                  


          temperature of the article which has already had its                        
          temperature raised by the radiant heat transfer section.                    
               Having carefully reviewed the teachings of each of                     
          LePisto, Heikkilä and Karlsson, we find nothing therein which               
          would indicate or suggest that the airborne unit of any of                  
          these applied references is capable of raising the temperature              
          of the web beyond the temperature to which it was raised in                 
          the radiant dryer, as required by each of the independent                   
          claims.  Indeed, there is no indication that the air which is               
          directed to the web for drying in the airborne unit is at a                 
          higher temperature than is the web after passing through the                
          radiant dryer.                                                              
               The examiner points out that, as admitted by appellants,               
          temperature controls for achieving the temperature rates                    
          recited by appellants are conventional in the heating art and               
          concludes from this that it would have been obvious to use                  
          conventional temperature control means to adjust the                        
          temperatures in the radiant and convection (airborne) sections              
          of any of the applied references to any desired temperature                 
          (answer, page 4).                                                           


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007