Ex Parte CARLSON et al - Page 9




          Appeal No. 2001-0258                                       Page 9           
          Application No. 08/821,978                                                  


          of altering the first chance means), thereby having no effect on            
          the player's strategy with respect to the first chance means.  In           
          the second variation (Figure 2), the second chance means is                 
          executed prior to the players's selection of the cards to hold              
          and discard, such that the player's strategy may be affected by             
          the outcome of the second chance means.  In the third variation             
          (Figure 3), the second chance means is executed prior to the                
          player's selection of hold and discard cards and alters the pay             
          table, thereby influencing the player's strategy with regard to             
          the first chance means.  In the fourth variation of the game                
          (Figure 4), the second chance means is executed after the                   
          player's selection of hold and discard cards and has no impact on           
          the player's strategy with regard to the first chance means.  As            
          disclosed in appellants' specification, each of these variations            
          appears to be a separate embodiment.  The specification contains            
          no disclosure of combining these variations in a single gaming              
          machine such that, in playing the game, a selection is made among           
          the four variations.  This inconsistency between the claim                  
          language and the underlying disclosure presents an ambiguity, as            
          discussed above, as to whether each of the above-mentioned                  
          independent claims is directed to a genus claim which covers two            
          species or whether a step of or means for selecting between two             







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007