Ex Parte LUGER - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2001-1280                                                        
          Application No. 07/977,163                                                  

          page 5 of appellant's specification, a blind-spot may be inward             
          (closer to the vehicle relative to the area visible in the                  
          conventional rearview mirror) or outward (further from the                  
          vehicle relative to the visible area).  In accordance with                  
          appellant's definition in the specification, a "blind-spot" as              
          used in appellant's claims is sufficiently broad to include                 
          inward or outward areas which are not visible to a driver in the            
          conventional rear-view mirror.                                              
               While much of the argument in appellant's brief is directed            
          to the orientation of the wedge-shaped support and the principal-           
          reflector-surface mirror relative to the conventional rearview              
          mirror (i.e., the thin edge of the wedge being closer to the                
          vehicle than the wide edge so as to direct the principal-                   
          reflector-surface mirror inward toward the vehicle), there is no            
          such limitation in claim 16.  Rather, claim 16 merely requires              
          two mirrors, with one of the mirrors supported on the other                 
          mirror by means of a wedge-shaped support structure.  From our              
          perspective, any orientation of the wedge would fall within the             
          scope of claim 16.                                                          
               Lawson discloses a side view mirror assembly 1 which is                
          attached through an arm or bracket 2 to the side of a vehicle 3.            
          The mirror assembly includes a housing 4, a flat mirror 5 and a             
                                          7                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007