Ex parte ERDMAN et al. - Page 9




             Appeal No. 1998-0507                                                                                     
             Application No. 08/457,701                                                                               


             across the dc bus and the motor has at least one winding and a rotor 6.  The motor 5 is                  
             responsive to a control circuit 9 for controlling current flow through a plurality of current            
             paths (i.e., current is conducted to each phase of the motor-see Abstract, lines 5-6), each              
             path including at least one coil of the motor winding.  Further, a control circuit is                    
             clearly activated to operate the motor.  Thus, Morinaga discloses the claimed invention but              
             for the specifics of a “capacitor across the rectifier input” for controlling the dc voltage on          
             the output side of the rectifier.                                                                        
                    While Gerfast is not directed to a “polyphase” dc motor, so it doesn’t disclose a                 
             “plurality of current paths,” Gerfast does clearly teach artisans to place a current limiting            
             capacitor at the input side of a rectifier in a circuit for operating a brushless dc motor.  See         
             column 2, line 67-column 3, line 8.  Gerfast teaches advantages of operating such a motor                
             from AC without a transformer, e.g., cost-savings and efficiency.  With the suggestion of                
             such advantages and no suggestion by Gerfast that there would be an impediment to                        
             applying such a current limiting capacitor to polyphase dc motors, it would appear to us                 
             that the artisan viewing both the Morinaga and Gerfast teachings as a whole would have                   
             been led to provide a current limiting capacitor at the input of the rectifier in the polyphase          
             dc motor of Morinaga in order to provide for the advantages taught by Gerfast in each of                 
             the phases of the dc motor of Morinaga.                                                                  




                                                          9                                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007