Appeal No. 1998-0942 Application No. 08/324,038 Representative independent claim 1 is reproduced as follows: 1. A portable electronic device with virtual display comprising a portable data source and a miniature virtual image display having a viewing aperture, the display being operably attached to the portable data source for receiving data therefrom and having image generation apparatus including a two-dimensional array of LEDs for providing a real image including one of a plurality of lines of alpha- numerics and graphics from the received data, the real image having a luminance of less than approximately 15 fL, and a fixed optical system for producing, from the real image, a virtual image with a dark background and shielded from ambient light reflection perceivable through the viewing aperture in indoor and outdoor environments. The examiner relies on the following references: Brennan et al. (Brennan) 4,076,978 Feb. 28, 1978 Nishizawa et al. (Nishizawa) 4,329,625 May 11, 1982 Villa-Real 4,481,382 Nov. 06, 1984 Honma 4,481,506 Nov. 06, 1984 Sakurai 4,991,935 Feb. 12, 1991 Tanielian et al. (Tanielian) 5,051,738 Sep. 24, 1991 Gaskill 5,065,423 Nov. 12, 1991 (Filed on Nov. 03, 1989) Sniff 5,485,145 Jan. 16, 1996 (Filed on Mar. 11, 1991) 3Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007