Ex parte HORTON et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1998-0999                                                        
          Application No. 08/452,737                                                  


               this type of construction allows for . . . the form                    
               of games to play, pictures to draw or [separate]                       
               adhesive stickers to adhere to the preprinted                          
               placemat.                                                              
          The separate adhesive stickers include pressure sensitive                   
          adhesive stickers. Id. The admittedly known prior art placemat              
          containing drawings and admittedly known stickers associated                
          therewith are closest to the claimed placemat.  The only                    
          distinction between the admittedly known prior art placemat                 
          containing drawings and separate stickers and the claimed                   
          placemat appears to be that the claimed placemat integrates                 
          conventional pressure sensitive adhesive stickers, such as                  
          those described in Ashby, Limina and Brown, with drawings                   
          associated therewith.                                                       
               Upon return of this application, the examiner is to                    
          determine whether one of ordinary skill in the art would have               
          been led or motivated to join or integrate conventional                     
          pressure adhesive stickers (such as those shown in Limina,                  
          Ashby and/or Brown), which are to be used with the drawings in              
          a placemat, with the placemat itself either for convenience or              
          for other practical reasons (such as connecting stickers to                 
          related drawings in a placemat to avoid misplacement or misuse              

                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007