Ex parte DAVIS - Page 4


          Appeal No. 1998-1005                                                         
          Application No. 08/362,042                                                   


          Nordness, Nowlin, and Packaging Technology.  (Examiner’s answer,             
          pages 4-6.)                                                                  
               We reverse this rejection.                                              
               Welborn describes ethylene polymers produced by                         
          polymerizing ethylene, either alone or in combination with other             
          monomers such as alpha-olefins, in the presence of a catalyst                
          composition comprising at least a cyclopentadienyl-transition                
          metal compound and an aluminoxane at elevated temperatures and               
          pressures.  (Column 3, lines 17-30.)  In Tables I and II,                    
          Welborn describes working examples of ethylene polymers having               
          densities within the range recited in the appealed claims.                   
          Further, Welborn teaches that the polymers have molecular weight             
          distributions (Mw/Mn) typically from 1.5 to 3.0 and that these               
          polymers "are capable of being fabricated into a wide variety of             
          articles, as is known for homopolymers of ethylene and                       
          copolymers of ethylene and higher alpha-olefins."  (Column 8,                
          lines 12-28.)                                                                
               As admitted by the examiner (examiner's answer, page 4),                
          Welborn does not disclose a food covered with a film or                      
          packaging including an ethylene polymer having the recited                   
          combination of properties.  To account for this difference, the              




                                          4                                            



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007