Ex parte WILLIAMS et al. - Page 15




          Appeall No. 1998-1398                                     Page 15           
          Application No. 08/400,637                                                  


               automatically generating a three way call as stated                    
               by claims 27 and 29 and the step of automatically                      
               terminating a path of the three way call as stated                     
               by claim [claims, sic] 28 and 30.  These steps have                    
               enabling descriptions as supported in the FIGs. 7-1,                   
               7-2 and 6-2 described in response to point 1                           
               hereinabove and as supported in the specification,                     
               for example, at page 14, line 23 - page 18, line 2                     
               ....                                                                   
          (Appeal Br. at 11).                                                         


               As mentioned regarding the written description rejection,              
          claims 27-30 specify in pertinent part the following                        
          limitations: “automatically generating a three way call ....”               
          As also aforementioned, claims 28 and 30 further specify in                 
          pertinent part the following limitations: “automatically                    
          terminating a path of the three way call ....”                              


               The examiner fails to show that the specification does                 
          not adequately enable the claimed limitations.  Even before                 
          the appellants’ invention, "landline and cellular telephone                 
          companies ... provided ... Three Way Calling."  (Spec. at 2.)               
          Turning to the invention, the specification explains that the               
          cordless base station can be implemented with "[a]                          
          conventional transmitter 301 and a conventional receiver 303,"              







Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007