Ex parte GREEN et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1998-1823                                       Page 4           
          Application No. 08/414,259                                                  


               Unlike the examiner, however, our review of the applied                
          references including the referred to portions of Kavalir does               
          not reveal any teaching or suggestion of dipping a form                     
          already covered with a layer of elastomeric material (casing)               
          in a solution including polyvinyl alcohol and a thickener as                
          required by the appealed claims.  While Kavalir does disclose               
          dipping a form covered with a latex material in a slip finish               
          of pre-cured resin-rubber latex (column 3, line 30 through                  
          column 5, line 8), we find no teaching of using polyvinyl                   
          alcohol and a thickener containing solution for coating a                   
          casing in Kavalir.                                                          
               We are mindful that Kavalir discloses dipping the form in              
          a coagulant solution containing alcohol and a mold release                  
          powder (column 4, lines 46-49), but that step occurs prior to               
          coating the form with an elastomeric material to form a                     
          casing.  Hence, even if the applied reference teachings are                 
          combined, the herein claimed process would not be the result.               
          Consequently, for the reasons outlined above and as developed               
          in appellants' brief (pages 4-7), we will not sustain the                   
          stated rejection.                                                           









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007