Ex parte NOTTINGHAM et al. - Page 2




             Appeal No. 1998-2314                                                          Page 2               
             Application No. 07/902,957                                                                         


                                                BACKGROUND                                                      
                   The appellants’ invention relates to a microwave popcorn package comprising                  
             container panels bonded together at their edges and so configured and graphically                  
             illustrated as to resemble, when inflated by the action of making the popcorn, an animate          
             object, a recognizable character or article, or an animal .  An understanding of the invention     
             can be derived from a reading of exemplary claims 1 and 37, which appear in the                    
             appendix to the  Brief.                                                                            
                   The prior art references of record relied upon by the examiner in rejecting the              
             appealed claims are:                                                                               
             Stoner                                 1,348,761                  Aug.  3, 1920                    
             Hirtzler                               1,715,757                  Jun.  4, 1929                    
             Walker                                 2,082,671                  Jun.   1, 1937                   
             Clark et al. (Clark)                   2,516,552                  Jul.  25, 1950                   
             Miller                                 2,698,496                  Jan.  4, 1955                    
             Panzer                                 3,442,043                  May  6, 1969                     
             Reese                                  3,835,308                  Sep.10, 1974                     
             Brandberg et al. (Brandberg ‘045)3,973,045                 Aug.  3, 1976                           
             Brandberg et al. (Brandberg ‘425)4,038,425                 Jul.  26, 1977                          
             Roccaforte et al. (Roccaforte)         4,453,665                  Jun. 12, 1984                    
             Bohrer et al. (Bohrer)                 4,678,882                  Jul.     7, 1987                 
             Winter                                 4,716,061                  Dec. 29, 1987                    
             Watkins et al. (Watkins)               4,735,513                  Apr.   5, 1988                   
             Larson                                 4,865,854                  Sep. 12, 1989                    
             Mendenhall et al. (Mendenhall)         4,874,620                  Oct. 17, 1989                    
             Ylvisaker                              4,892,744                  Jan.   9, 1990                   
             Burkes                           Des. 161,734                     Jan. 30, 1951                    










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007