Ex parte MELTON et al. - Page 7

             Appeal No. 1998-3053                                                                                 
             Application 08/677,755                                                                               


             created doctrine of obviousness-type double patenting over                                           
             claim 1 of Melton ‘453 in view of Tulman, and under 35 U.S.C.                                        
             § 103 over Melton ‘341 in view of Tulman, are reversed.                                              
                                                   REVERSED                                                       





                                 CHUNG K. PAK                            )                                        
                                 Administrative Patent Judge             )                                        
                                                                        )                                        
                                                                        )                                        
                                                                        )                                        
                                 TERRY J. OWENS                                 )  BOARD OF                       
             PATENT                                                                                               
                                 Administrative Patent Judge             )  APPEALS AND                           
                                                                        )  INTERFERENCES                         
                                                                        )                                        
                                                                        )                                        
                                 PAUL LIEBERMAN                                 )                                 
                                 Administrative Patent Judge             )                                        


             TJO/ki                                                                                               
             Motorola, Inc.                                                                                       
             Intellectual Property Department                                                                     
             Corporate Office                                                                                     
             1303 E. Algonquin Road                                                                               
             Schaumburg, IL  60196                                                                                





                                                      -7-7                                                        





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7

Last modified: November  3, 2007