Ex parte YKEMA - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-3076                                                        
          Application 08/303,046                                                      


               Based upon the foregoing, we agree with the examiner that              
          the broadly recited limitations of claims 16 through 21 and 33              
          through 35 and 37 read on the teachings of Bilas.  In claim                 
          16, the “branches for distributing power within said system to              
          various loads” is broad enough to read on the exit power lines              
          14 in Bilas, and the “at least one branch for connection to a               
          power supply” is broad enough to read on the input power lines              
          12 in Bilas.  Any one of the circuit breakers 20 in Bilas is                
          connected                                                                   
          to a node in the load center 10 “for selectably functionally                
          controlling power flow between said power supply and load                   
          branches.”  The node means of claim 16 is not described as a                
          “multimodular multicomponent” subsystem (reply brief, page 2).              
          The circuit breakers 20 in Bilas provide “over current                      
          protection” to the loads (claims 17 and 20) (brief, pages 14                
          and 15).  Each of the bus boards 16 and 18 in Bilas functions               
          as a backplane/bus bar, and a plurality of nodes are in the                 
          bus boards.  The programmable controller 32 in Bilas (Figure                
          1a) is “at least one control module for controlling                         
          performance of selected functions, having a generally planar                
          side with means thereon for complementally electrically                     

                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007