Ex parte BENIGNUS et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1999-0246                                                        
          Application 08/641,629                                                      

          ("Remote Mode - SYSTEM") gives system console capabilities to               
          the remote terminal operator (col. 9, ll. 44-50).  Command U                
          ("Remote Mode - USER") gives user terminal capabilities to the              
          remote terminal operator (col. 10, ll. 11-16).  Command N                   
          ("Remote Mode - NONE") is used to "un-patch" the remote                     
          terminal, i.e., to exit the SYSTEM mode or USER mode (col. 9,               
          ll. 56-65).  On the other hand, Command V ("Configuration                   
          VIEW/CHANGE"), which is used to view and change the parameters              
          of the various serial ports, can be entered via the remote                  
          terminal in the NONE, LIMITED, and FULL positions of the                    
          keyswitch (col. 10, ll. 22-23).                                             


               In the final Office action (Paper No. 17), which                       
          incorporates the preceding Office action (Paper No. 15), the                
          examiner read the claimed "physical key having three positions              
          corresponding to a normal/run mode, a secure mode, and a                    
          service mode" (emphasis added) on Smitt's three-position                    
          keyswitch 97 and relied on Heptig as teaching the claimed                   
          "electronic key having three positions corresponding to a                   
          normal/run mode, a secure mode, and a service mode" (emphasis               
          added).  However, in the Answer (at 4), the examiner reversed               

                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007