Ex parte SAKA et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-0304                                                        
          Application No. 08/520,606                                                  


          and function differs from the claimed invention.  We agree                  
          with appellants.                                                            
               Caiati discloses (column 6, lines 13-17 and 55-61) that:               
               [w]hen the contents of the shift register 48 have                      
               been read into the memory system 52, . . . the                         
               memory address counter and decoder 51 supplies a                       
               shutdown enable signal SDE to the power supply 32                      
               which is disabled thereby to prevent any further                       
               information from being monitored by the solid state                    
               crash recorder.                                                        
                    . . . .                                                           
                    . . . When the shutdown enable signal SDE is                      
               generated, the SCR 66 is gated on to short the                         
               battery to ground through the fuse 58.  The current                    
               through the fuse 58 is sufficient to cause it to                       
               open the circuit from the DC voltage source 54.                        
               Consequently, the solid state crash recorder is                        
               thereafter disabled.                                                   
          In other words, the grounding element is not directly                       
          connected to a crash sensor nor does it act in response to a                
          direct signal from a crash sensor, as recited in the claims.                
          Instead, the grounding element receives an enable signal from               
          memory and address counter and decoder 51, and the signal is                
          received only after the contents of the shift register 48 have              
          been read into memory.  Accordingly, Caiati's structure and                 



                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007