Ex parte EISENHARDT et al. - Page 4




              Appeal No. 1999-1229                                                                                      
              Application 08/543,975                                                                                    
              oryzae, or by limiting the milk and dairy products in their diet to only those which had been             
              pre-hydrolyzed.  Specification, pp. 1-2.                                                                  
                     As indicated by the claims, the present invention is generally directed to a                       
              composition for hydrolyzing lactose which comprises two different lactases which function                 
              optimally within different pH ranges.  In addition, the invention is directed to various                  
              compositions which comprise a lactase derived from either Aspergillus oryzae or                           
              Aspergillus niger and Kluyveromyces lactis.  The lactase derived from K. lactis can be                    
              enterically coated to prevent deactivation by the gastric enzymes of the stomach                          
              environment.                                                                                              
                                                    DISCUSSION                                                          
                     The examiner’s conclusion of obviousness is said to be based on the teachings of                   
              Barillas, Rosado, Medow, Gekas, Kan and Sipos.                                                            
                     To that end, we find that Barillas and Rosado disclose the administration of a                     
              lactase derived either from the yeast K. lactis or from the fungus A. niger, to randomly-                 
              selected children and to healthy and lactose-intolerant adults, respectively.  The authors                
              quantify lactose absorption using a modified hydrogen breath analysis procedure.                          
              According to the examiner, the authors note a difference in the activity of the two enzymes,              
              but she does not explain what the difference is, or its significance.  Answer, p. 4.                      
                     Medow discloses that the co-administration of lactose and lactase-containing tablets               
              reduced the hydrogen breath secretion in 16 of 18 lactose-intolerant children by 89%.                     


                                                           4                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007