Ex parte SCHINDLER et al. - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1999-1605                                                         
          Application 08/502,882                                                       

          without infecting [sic, affecting] each other (see figure 1,                 
          column 4, lines 67-68 and column 5, lines 1-2)."                             
               Rickenbach relates to a software system which fuses the                 
          display outputs of a plurality of independent application                    
          programs into a single overlayed screen display (abstract;                   
          col. 1, lines 12-17).  However, the Examiner relies on the                   
          description of the prior art rather than what Rickenbach                     
          discloses as the invention.  Fig. 1 shows a conceptual layout                
          of a prior art windowing system having a plurality of                        
          application programs 16, 18 generating output displays in                    
          windows 10, 12.  User interfaces (software) 23, 24 for each                  
          program 16, 18 provide interfaces to the user input devices                  
          25, 26 for each application program.  Although Fig. 1                        
          conceptually shows different application programs 16, 18                     
          responsive to different groups of input devices 25, 26,                      
          Rickenbach discloses that the groups of input devices are, in                
          fact, the same input devices used successively (col. 5,                      
          lines 22-26):  "Windowing management system 14 further permits               
          the user to switch into, out of and between application                      
          programs 16 and 18 so that input devices such as the keyboards               
          and mouse controls may be operated with each application                     

                                        - 10 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007