Appeal No. 1999-1612
Application 08/614,188
paragraph, of Bellcore ‘030 and to page 1, section 1.3, second
paragraph; page 3, section 3.1.1.2., first paragraph; page 11,
section 3.8, first and second paragraphs; and page 14, section
3.10, first and second paragraphs, of Bellcore ‘031, 1986.
Bellcore ‘030 is “Bellcore’s view of proposed generic
requirements for SPCS Customer Premise Equipment Data
Interface.” Section 1.1, page 1, acknowledges that while it3
is possible to send data when Customer Premise Equipment (CPE)
is in an off-hook or an on-hook condition, “in an off-hook
state, additional complexities arise regarding interrupting an
existing voice conversation during data transmission.” This
section also notes that “[t]hese complexities are beyond the
scope of this document, so the off-hook case is not addressed
herein.” We find that these passages do not provide any
details which would show that the skilled artisan had
necessary details needed on how to make and use an invention
which requires transmission of caller identification data
during an off-hook state. This passage, in fact, implies that
3See page iii of the reference.
5
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007